Bay Street Hotel Restaurant in Sodus Point

8427 Bay St, Sodus Point, NY 14555-9540, Sodus Point

Overview

Cuisine
  • American
  • Caribbean
  • International
  • Gluten Free Options
Features
  • Reservations
  • Seating
  • Waitstaff
  • Wheelchair Accessible
  • Serves Alcohol
Good for
  • Bar scene
  • Romantic
  • Special occasions

Restaurant Hours

Monday

Closed

Tuesday

Closed

Wednesday

4:00 pm

Friday

4:00 pm

Sunday

12:00 pm

Does the restaurant close during winter? If so, when?

In the past New Year's Eve was the last night.

Are you open for dinners on Wednesday night? 10/10/18?

Call and make a reservation! They are open Wednesday through Sunday

Is there a place to view menu and other pertinent info?

Yes

Review

Add rating restaurant:
Bay Street Hotel Restaurant
FS
Frederick Stuber
google
11.10.2018
5/5

Great food, great atmosphere, great people, great martinis!

Bay Street Hotel Restaurant
MG
Marie Gunkel
google
10.22.2018
5/5

The best food and drink.. Mojto is the best I ever had!!I

Bay Street Hotel Restaurant
BW
Barbara Wills
google
10.04.2018
5/5

Stopped with family for martinis. Interesting place. Old, eccentric. But felt comfortable. Throw back to 50s or 60s.

Bay Street Hotel Restaurant
DA
Daniel Armstrong
google
09.07.2018
5/5

Awesome, awesome place. Dinner was everything I would have hoped it would be and the martini menu is top notch!

Bay Street Hotel Restaurant
GG
Ginger Gilbert
google
08.22.2018
5/5

Love the people Love the place Love the food. Most of all. I love the LOVE!!!

Bay Street Hotel Restaurant
BL
Bill L.
google
08.15.2018
5/5

Fine dining with a Key West/ Caribbean flair, paired with the finest cocktails you can imagine, and served up in a warm and welcoming atmosphere by the best chefs, wait staff, and mixologsts you could ask for. One of the happiest places you'll ever visit.

Bay Street Hotel Restaurant
MF
Michel Fournelle
google
07.18.2018
4/5

Great food but portion are huge. Should offer half portion even for 75% of the price....

Bay Street Hotel Restaurant
BF
Brooke Ferguson
google
07.02.2018
5/5

My favorite place to go for dinner and drinks when I am at sodus point. They have a great martini menu and I’ve never had a bad meal there. It is casual dining so the clientele a more mature class of people which makes it an enjoyable atmosphere.

Bay Street Hotel Restaurant
MV
Matthew Vincent
google
05.25.2018
5/5

Was so surprised by the insides. It was a fun Key West style bar with a a great selection of cocktails. Really serious mixology. I didn't dine but the menu looked great. Seriously was not expecting a tropical paradise inside, it looks like a country barn bar outside.

Bay Street Hotel Restaurant
MT
Melissa Thiel
google
05.21.2018
5/5

Wonderful place to enjoy martinis. Had the raspberry truffle and shamrock mint and they were fantastic. Family favorite.

Bay Street Hotel Restaurant
SS
Scott Schabel
google
05.14.2018
5/5

Always outstanding. Bay Street is a guaranteed great experience, not just a meal. You start with an extensive offering of martinis and Manhattans complimented by a remarkable wine list. The appetizers and entrées are far from the "bar and grill" offerings available elsewhere in the area. Everything is fresh and prepared to order. Intertwined with the food is truly professional service. Of course such an experience is not cheap, but it is worth every penny, especially when you have something to really celebrate. Make your reservation early so their availability can match your schedule.

Bay Street Hotel Restaurant
DW
Denise Washburn
google
05.10.2018
5/5

Wonderful wait staff. Excellent food. A treat for new years.

Bay Street Hotel Restaurant
NS
Nelson Scutt, Jr.
google
05.03.2018
5/5

If I could eat here every weekend I would!! To the owners&the staff,they are always on,I highly recommend this place,had another amazing dinner last night......I suggest the filet with the feta stuffed shrimp, service is always on cue........💕

Bay Street Hotel Restaurant
MD
Mary DeLisio
google
05.01.2018
5/5

Love this place! The food is great and the martini's are wonderful!

Bay Street Hotel Restaurant
DL
David Lynch
google
03.23.2018
5/5

Excellent food and very attentive wait staff. Had a family get together there and enjoyed the entire experience. Martini Bar has some unusual fare and goes well with the relaxed atmosphere and great staff.

Bay Street Hotel Restaurant
WH
William H. Butterworth
google
03.13.2018
5/5

Great place to relax and enjoy craft cocktails and lively banter

Bay Street Hotel Restaurant
KW
Kelly Waters
google
03.03.2018
5/5

Good food but pricy for Wayne County.

Bay Street Hotel Restaurant
TB
Tom Belknap
google
02.17.2018
2/5

Over priced for what you get!

Bay Street Hotel Restaurant
RW
Ray Wellington
google
02.02.2018
5/5

The Oreo Martini was the perfect start to an outstanding meal. Would definitely go again.

Bay Street Hotel Restaurant
PR
Paul Redden
google
11.26.2017
5/5

Ladies love the Martinis at the Bay Street, they have a menu just for them! ( The chocolate one is a fan favorite). After a day of playing on the water, the Bay Street is one of several off the water/walking distance destinations for food and drinks with friends. You can get a great burger there but their chef's prepare a menu with specialty items that are a cut above the rest. Limited tables so make reservations early.

Bay Street Hotel Restaurant
DM
Danya Matthys
google
11.20.2017
5/5

Most favorite restaurant bar in the world

Bay Street Hotel Restaurant
JF
Julie Fox
google
10.25.2017
5/5

Love this place. Awesome food and awesome martinis!!!

Bay Street Hotel Restaurant
UO
U OL
google
10.22.2017
5/5

Excellent food and service.

Bay Street Hotel Restaurant
AT
Amanda Timmerman
google
10.16.2017
5/5

Always a great time here!! They have the best martinis around hands down. Great food inside and a food truck outside serving awesome food after hours all summer long!!!

Bay Street Hotel Restaurant
JA
Jim Alexander
google
10.10.2017
3/5

I can't comment on atmosphere or food because I haven't been there. Reason being I like to review menu before going for first time and they don't have one online. I sent message to them and they said it is on FB under photos. Seriously. I have to look through almost 1200 pictures to find your menu. I guess if you are too lazy to post menu, then how good can food or service be.

Bay Street Hotel Restaurant
MS
Miriam S
google
09.02.2017
5/5

As always..food was delicious service excellent. A bit noisy​ but I think that was our party of eleven.!!

Bay Street Hotel Restaurant
AM
Amanda Morgan
google
08.25.2017
5/5

We started out by choosing a martini! A little difficult since there are so many to choose from, but I love choices! Also the bartenders are very nice and willing to help you find your right martini match! The martinis are strong and so delicious! Then we were seated for dinner, we started with oysters Tiffany and they were AMAZING! The seasoning on the perfectly fried oysters was a mouthful of ocean heaven and then the mornay sauce on top just put them over the edge! I had the special of Chilean sea bass with a cheese soufflé sauce. The fish was perfectly cooked and huge! Give this place a try! You won’t be disappointed!

Bay Street Hotel Restaurant
VP
Vaughn Petersen
google
07.23.2017
5/5

Great food. Unique decor,. Friendly staff and clientele

Bay Street Hotel Restaurant
CC
Cynthia Care
google
06.23.2017
5/5

Awesome martini selection!

Bay Street Hotel Restaurant
AL
Andy Litzinger
google
05.22.2017
5/5

This is the best place to eat and drink in Sodus Point! Amazing food and Martini's.

Bay Street Hotel Restaurant
LC
Lawrence Comeau
google
03.22.2017
5/5

Excellent fresh food and great service.

Bay Street Hotel Restaurant
WS
William Snyder
google
03.20.2017
5/5

Incredible list of Martini's

Bay Street Hotel Restaurant
MC
Matt C
google
03.14.2017
5/5

Great experience. Highly recommend going here for a fine dinner or just drinks. Food and drinks are top notch, service was outstanding. The cleanliness was a shock... I always have to clean my silverware at every place I have ever dined, not here silverware was spotless. I tip my hat to the owners for an excellent experience.

Bay Street Hotel Restaurant
TP
Tim Pettine
google
01.15.2017
5/5

Iconic place for dinner and drinks. One of the best in Western NY.

Bay Street Hotel Restaurant
CH
Candi House
google
01.02.2017
4/5

We had alot of fun at their Mardi gras party! Food was great but very expensive! A steak at a bar/restaurant should not have the same price tag as one from a steak house when they aren't as delicious.

Bay Street Hotel Restaurant
RN
Richard Norris
google
10.24.2016
5/5

The bar area was very busy when we arrived with several friends. The 2 bartenders were looking at something in their cell phones for at least 5 minutes, which was frustrating. They apologized after they realized people had been waiting for drinks. After that they were very good. They are known for their Martinis

Bay Street Hotel Restaurant
KD
Kim Davies
google
10.09.2016
5/5

Drinks where amazing an food was just as amazing

Bay Street Hotel Restaurant
NG
Nick Gulisano
google
10.04.2016
5/5

Great drinks and great people, that make up a great atmosphere.

Bay Street Hotel Restaurant
SB
Steven Bates
google
09.20.2016
5/5

The owners and staff are very friendly and the food is great as well as consistent. They have a large selection of Martini's to meet anyone's taste. If you haven't been there it's worth the trip and if you have been there, then you will be back.

Bay Street Hotel Restaurant
mT
mike Tumm
google
09.11.2016
5/5

Great bartender!

Bay Street Hotel Restaurant
TL
Tina L
google
08.18.2016
5/5

Great Martinis and atmosphere. Food truck outside is nice for less expensive food choices

Bay Street Hotel Restaurant
TW
Teri Webster
google
08.15.2016
5/5

Small intimate place with delicious food. It's not cheap but worth every cent. I would highly recommend it.

Bay Street Hotel Restaurant
WH
William Hood
google
08.04.2016
2/5

Over priced

Bay Street Hotel Restaurant
KH
Kathryn Humbert
google
06.27.2016
5/5

Food is amazing. Cozy place for a night out

Bay Street Hotel Restaurant
CP
Char Passero
google
06.15.2016
1/5

We were in there earlier today and ordered one of the specialty martinis that included ice cream. We had been there before and drove a half hour to have this particular drink. The young bartender gave us the drink without the ice cream. She mumbled that it would come later. How does one serve a drink with ingredients missing? The bartender was very rude about it. When she got the ice cream about 10 minutes later she then through the little spoon in the drink. I would not go back to this place because of the service. The owner or manager did come by but offered nothing but That it had been a bad start to the evening. I would have expected a more professional bartender in this type of place.

Bay Street Hotel Restaurant
CD
Catherine Decker
google
06.14.2016
4/5

Love going there, never disappointed

Bay Street Hotel Restaurant
RJ
Raymond Johnston
google
03.17.2016
1/5

Order two take out dinners. They were ready on time and delicious. Unfortunately when I walked in the bartender had her face mask down talking to two people side by side at the bar.. the bartender pulled up her face mask when she saw meIt was another man sitting down at the bar at the end with no face covering. Signs seem to imply a ideological tilt. I hope this is received as constructive criticism

Bay Street Hotel Restaurant
JF
Jumpy Films
google
03.12.2016
5/5

The owners and staff are amazing. Great fresh food, superb service and friendliest staff I've ever experienced. I feel like a queen every time I frequent this establishment! Thank you For the best time out everything !!

Bay Street Hotel Restaurant
MD
Melanie DeBadts
google
02.13.2016
5/5

A little something for everyone here. Always greeted with a smile!

Bay Street Hotel Restaurant
by
bill yarbrough
google
01.20.2016
5/5

Excellent menu! Gr8 food! Gr8 service. Martinis to die for!

Your question has been sent.

Expect an answer!

Thank!

Your review has been submitted.

Order food

Reservation

Want to order over the phone?

Call 13154832233

Thank you for being with us!

We will call you back!